The Ecommerce Optimization Guide for Black Friday & Cyber Monday

The Good
19 min readNov 11, 2022

The ultimate Cyber Monday and Black Friday guide for ecommerce businesses gearing up for holiday traffic.

2021 brought the first ever $200+ billion holiday season in the US, according to research from Adobe.

Online spending grew 8.6% over the previous holiday season and 44% over 2019.

Assuming this year follows similar trends, there is a lot of money on the table.

If you haven’t started, it’s time to optimize your website to win big this year, and this Cyber Monday and Black Friday guide will help you do it.

Keep reading to see the three-step optimization process to complete before the holiday traffic strikes.

  • Step 1: Conduct a Website Audit
  • Step 2: Optimize Your User Experience
  • Step 3: Re-evaluate Your Sales Strategy

Step 1: Conduct a Website Audit

Conducting a thorough review of your website prior to the Cyber Monday and Black Friday shopping season will set your business up for success.

You have just a few short weeks to identify holes in your conversion funnel before the holiday traffic surge arrives.

Technical Review

Start with a technical audit of your website. Before you can dive into improving your website’s customer journey, you need to ensure that it’s technically functioning at its best.

Site Speed

Having a fast ecommerce site is the difference between conversion and abandonment.

For every millisecond your site delays in loading, you could lose up to 1% in online revenue. Unfortunately, for a lot of ecommerce managers, optimizing a website’s load speed is often overlooked and languishes at the bottom of the priority list.

Many brands, content with the quickness of their homepage, forget that their product pages, category pages, and shopping cart’s load speeds matter just as much. Having a homepage that loads in 2 seconds is great, but if your shopping cart takes 10 seconds to load (or worse, times out) you will lose a sale.

So how do you properly analyze your website’s speed and pinpoint areas that are causing loading delays?

Google PageSpeed Insights is a great resource to start with and if you’re looking for a more advanced tool to help identify load speed problems, GTmetrix can help.

If you want to accomplish a thorough analysis and improvement on your site speed, here is our 15 step guide.

Website Analytics Funnel Analysis

Funnel analysis allows you to visualize the journey your visitors take to complete a task and observe how they’re succeeding or failing at each step. The insights you’ll gain from this type of analysis will help identify where in their journey customers are experiencing problems so you can prioritize those areas as part of the optimization process.

If you’re still learning the ins and outs of Google Analytics (or whichever analytics platform you’re using), consider reading our Insight article that explains the most effective approach to conducting a funnel analysis of your site. You can also use our step-by-step guide to setting up a custom funnel analysis in Google Analytics.

User-Experience Review

Analyzing the user experience of your website is an essential step to consider before moving on to testing. Evaluating your website analytics helps you identify the specific pages on your site that may be causing problems for your customers.

The three key components to conducting a successful user-experience review are…

  1. Eye-tracking heatmaps
  2. Session recordings and user testing
  3. Talking to customers and customer service representatives

Eye-tracking heatmaps

First, let’s focus on heatmaps — a tool we use on a daily basis at The Good. Eye-tracking heatmaps provide a visual representation of typical user behavior by aggregating data showing where users click, move, and scroll on a webpage.

Heatmaps may not provide the breadth and variety of data you’ll receive from a website analytics tool, but they work very well for quickly diagnosing problems that could potentially be costing you sales.

Hotjar is an excellent tool if you’re serious about optimizing your website experience. It provides heatmap reports based on the clicks and movements of customers on your site.

Session Recordings

Next, let’s talk about session recordings. Session recordings (also referred to as session replays) are one of the essential tools you’ll need to conduct a comprehensive website audit.

As the name implies, these recordings capture the mouse movements, clicks, and scrolls that a visitor executes while browsing your website. Session recordings provide an unbiased look at how real customers behave on your site and play a key role in helping you uncover potential usability challenges.

At The Good, session recordings are an essential part of our UX research process. Having the opportunity to observe how real customers navigate a website is invaluable knowledge that will make your conversion rate optimization efforts all the more impactful.

User testing

User testing is another method of research that works in tandem with session recordings. This research technique involves asking “user testers” in your target audience to complete specific tasks on your site.

While the tester is completing the assigned tasks, their screen is recorded and they’re usually asked to narrate their thoughts on the browsing experience.

The knowledge you’ll take away from even just a handful of user-testing sessions will be invaluable to the optimization process later on.

Recommended tools for session recordings and user testing:

  • — With a range of user-testing options, you can get quick and in-depth user feedback on your site. Real people will record their live impressions of your site, so you can make sure their experience is exactly as you want it to be.
  • UserTesting — This is another tool for conducting remote, unmonitored user testing. After you input the specific demographic information of your target audience, this service will hand-pick a group of user testers who meet your criteria to participate in tests.

Talking to customers and customer service representatives

The last (and arguably most important) task you should take into consideration when conducting a website audit is speaking directly with your customers. You’d be surprised by how many ecommerce managers we talk to who have never invested in focus groups or in-depth customer surveys.

Tools like CMNTY and Remesh make it very easy to conduct an online focus group and get valuable insights directly from your customers in real-time.

There’s no better way to understand how your customers perceive your website than talking with them directly. Investing in just one focus group session will provide more than enough insight to fuel your next round of A/B tests.

In addition to focus groups and in-depth interviews, you might consider opening a direct line of communication between your UX designer(s) and your customer support team.

It’s not uncommon for there to be a disconnect between these two teams, especially for larger ecommerce companies or if customer service is outsourced to a third party. Creating a feedback loop between these teams may unearth latent problems that can then be addressed quickly by your ecommerce manager or UX designer.

Step 2: Optimize Your User Experience

After identifying the specific challenges and conversion blockers that are hindering sales on your site, the next step is optimizing your user experience.

The three key areas of we recommend focusing your attention on are your:

  1. Homepage
  2. Product Pages
  3. Checkout Page


A critical mistake we see ecommerce managers make is insisting that their homepage is the most important place on their site. They’ll invest a majority of their time (or their developer’s time) trying to make it the most beautifully designed page of the site with complete disregard for the rest of the customer experience.

Here’s the problem with this approach: Putting most of your resources into designing an aesthetically appealing homepage is like investing all of your automotive budget into a new paint job, then not having funds left over to buy gas or repair the engine. It’ll look good, but it won’t get you far.

That said, the homepage does play an important role in your customer’s journey. Your homepage should accomplish something in a major way that every subsequent page on your site should echo: let visitors know exactly where they are, what they can do there, and how to take the next step forward.

Unfortunately, many brands misuse the homepage as a dumping ground for all things marketing, neglecting the wayfinding purpose of the page.

Here’s what we recommend you do to get your homepage optimized before the BFCM traffic starts pouring in:

1. Revisit your value proposition

Visitors direct their attention to your value proposition when deciding if they need what you’re selling. If they don’t fully understand the value that you can provide for them they’ll leave your site.

If you don’t already have a value proposition, look at your unique selling proposition (USP) to aid in developing one. If you can clearly describe what makes your company unique, you’ll be better equipped to explain to your customers why they should choose you over the competition.

This template is a good place to start:

  • Target audience: Be as specific as possible so you attract the interest of the prospects who matter. If you’re targeting digital marketers, be specific about that.
  • Target objective: The objective is revealed when you’re determining your customers’ immediate needs. If your target audience’s goal is to improve their search engine optimization strategy, speak to that need.
  • Unique selling proposition: Explain what value you can provide through your products/services. This is the unique solution that you’re selling to your audience.

One way to make sure your home page is delivering on all of the above, is to have an acquaintance perform a 5-second test (usually friends and family are too close to give real, raw feedback).

Go to a local coffee shop and offer to buy someone a coffee for a few minutes of their time. Show them your website and ask them to tell you about the first things they notice.

Are those things the most important? If not, how can you improve your homepage to make sure in 5-seconds anyone knows what your site is about. Check out our landing page optimization rubric for more information.

2. Optimize your navigation menu

Website navigation can make or break your visitors’ experience. Attempting to navigate a website that doesn’t have a logical, well-defined structure is like being dropped in the middle of a complex maze with no map and no frame of reference.

It’s overwhelming, frustrating, and all-around unpleasant — not exactly the user experience you’re hoping for.

  • Optimize your mobile website’s navigation. Having a navigation menu appropriate for a mobile device is essential to any ecommerce website. Consumers expect the mobile experience of a website to be as good, if not better than the desktop experience. Provide your visitors with a responsive, optimized navigation bar and you’re guaranteed to see an improvement in your mobile conversion rate.
  • Make site search frictionless. Visitors who use search typically have intent to buy or act. Plus, they’re much more likely to find what they’re looking for. People who run a site search convert buyers approximately two times more often than people who don’t.

3. Remove any unnecessary distractions

First, if you’re currently using a nonrotating carousel on your homepage, we strongly recommend removing it.

Research has shown that a staggeringly low 1% of site visitors click nonrotating image carousels (carousels that don’t change automatically). Additionally, 84% of those clicks are on the first slide, meaning all the remaining slides combined receive a dismal 16% of the clicks.

The numbers aren’t much better for carousels that rotate automatically. Auto-rotating carousels receive a bit more attention, but again, the first slide dominates, receiving 40% of all clicks. The second and third positions receive 18% and 11% fewer clicks.

While it may seem like a good idea to use a carousel, the numbers simply don’t back it up. The click-through rate (CTR) on carousels is abysmally low, with the lion’s share of clicks being gobbled up by the first slide.

Another distraction you’ll often find on an ecommerce homepage is the “Sign-up for our email list!” pop-up. In general, we recommend that you stay away from pop-ups that detract from the browsing experience.

Product Page

If you plan on investing in paid traffic this holiday season, it’s important you’re making sure your product pages are properly optimized to get the most out of that traffic.

To optimize your product pages for a better conversion rate, we recommend you focus on:

1. Product naming conventions

When it comes to product naming conventions for your products and product categories, the more descriptive, the better. The reason for this is that each word is a potential keyword for organic search.

Google favors product pages that have descriptive titles because it allows users to find exactly what they’re looking for. Long names also implicitly indicate more value and stand a better chance of attracting the visitor’s attention.

2. Product descriptions

Great copy begins with an understanding of the audience — their needs, their desires, their problems, and the words they use to describe them.

The copy should be presented in a scannable, jargon-free format, with benefits highlighted to spell out exactly what the product will do for the potential customer. Use white space to help keep your product page layout clean and easily readable.

The product description should provide critical product information, short-circuit objections, and provide answers to the visitor’s most pressing questions.

3. Product photography / video

This is where your writers and designers join forces. High-quality images or illustrations lend credence to the copywriter’s product description.

Show people wearing and using your products to give the prospect a glimpse of ownership.

Your headlines and product images should work together to establish the product’s value and illustrate why the prospect would be wise to select it.

The practice of including video elements in the digital assets strategy has risen so dramatically that many ecommerce sites now consider videos essential. Do people worry your product is difficult to use? Video can disprove that concern by demonstrating that the owner only needs to follow a few simple directions.

Do customers want to know more about the difference between certain features? Video can describe those differences quickly and accurately.

4. Back-in-stock notifications

If you’re prone to running out of stock on certain items during the holiday shopping season, you need to have a solid back-in-stock notification option to recapture those sales when your stock is replenished.

There are a few things you can do to ensure you don’t miss out on sales when a product goes out-of-stock:

  • Use back-in-stock emails. Work on your back-in-stock emails themselves. There are a few details to note here. Include the brand, the product, and its best price in the email subject line. In the body of the email, we recommend including an image and mentioning the brand, product name, and price again. You can also include a reminder of why they are receiving the email, clearly explain that it’s back-in-stock, and include a very clear call-to-action that brings them to the exact product in the store.
  • Use SMS and push alerts. SMS text is quickly becoming one of the most effective ways to reach customers. Providing customers with the option to input their mobile number instead of an email address may be an even more impactful way to notify customers that an item is back-in-stock.


According to Statista, over 69% of visitors who load items into an ecommerce shopping cart end up not finishing the transaction. For one reason or another, they abandon the cart.

The money online retailers invested in advertising, social media, content development — every sales and marketing expense you can name — has contributed to getting someone right to the brink of the purchase. But that person decides to walk away.

Improving your shopping cart conversion rate is the spot where your ecommerce optimization dollars will pay off best. It’s the ideal place to begin.

Here are several items to consider when optimizing your checkout process:

1. Evaluate your post-purchase follow-up

Reevaluate your post-purchase follow-up procedure to ensure customers are receiving the best possible service even after they complete a purchase.

Despite the statistics, most marketers give little time or thought to their post-purchase email sequences. They send a receipt and little else. This is missing out on a significant opportunity to convert new customers into recurring customers. Here are the post-purchase emails we recommend you include in your post-purchase follow-up sequence:

  • The order confirmation. The first email should always be the confirmation of purchase. When people click Buy, they want to know that everything worked. That they didn’t just send money into the ether of the internet, never to hear from it again. Confirm that their order was received and that someone on the other end is doing something about it.
  • The shipping confirmation. The shipping confirmation email allows you to update the customer on the status of their order, continue to build trust with them, and nurture your relationship with them.
  • The shipment update. Approximately one week after their shipment should have arrived, you want to check in to make sure everything arrived in good condition. This is also an excellent opportunity to entice the customer with complimentary products or sign them up for a recurring purchase plan.
  • The review request. Always make sure the final email you send is a review request. After the customer has had time to use the product, make sure to politely ask them to submit a review and let you know what they thought of the product.

2. Hide the discount code field

With the rising popularity of discount-finder apps like Honey and Wikibuy, consumers have grown to expect a discount on every purchase made while online shopping. Unless your business is relying on discounts to draw in new customers, showing this form field to users is only going to encourage them to leave your site in search of a discount or promo code. After they leave your site, it’s very unlikely they’ll return empty-handed to complete the purchase at full price.

We always recommend hiding the discount code field (even completely removing it) so visitors aren’t tempted to go searching for coupon codes somewhere on the internet.

3. Offer free shipping

For retailers, it’s important to consider both the short-term and long-term benefits of offering free shipping. In the short term, offering free shipping will likely lead to an increase in orders and a higher average order value (AOV), especially if you set a minimum order threshold that your customers need to reach before they “unlock” free shipping.

Sixty percent of ecommerce businesses report that “free shipping with conditions” is their most successful marketing tool. If adding one more item to the shopping cart results in getting free two-day shipping, most consumers will do it.

In the long-term, offering free shipping will benefit your business by increasing customer lifetime value, and helping you build a group of loyal repeat purchasers. Additionally, it can be a great way to maintain your competitive edge in the marketplace, especially if you’re operating in an industry that sells commonly available products, or even commodity products that compete heavily on price.

4. Implement a one-page checkout process

The checkout page is easily one of the most crucial, yet often overlooked elements of an ecommerce website. If your checkout process is too lengthy or complicated, you’re seriously hindering sales for your business. We always recommend implementing a one-page checkout.

A single-page checkout simplifies the checkout procedure and eliminates any additional steps in the customer journey that could potentially contribute to cart abandonment. The one-page checkout template comes standard with most major ecommerce platforms (Shopify, BigCommerce, Magento) so there’s really no reason to not have it on your site.

Integrate social proof throughout the customer journey

Implementing social proof on your site can be one of the most effective methods for increasing your overall conversion rate. Sixty-one percent of customers read online reviews before choosing to buy a product or service.

If everyone is buzzing about a newly-released movie, and I’m hearing nothing but recommendations to go see it, I’m quite likely to go. On the other hand, if the reviews are sour and my friends tell me the movie was a waste of time and money, I’ll skip it..

Human beings are social creatures. We want to fit in. Our tendency is to do what others are doing, even if we pride ourselves on individuality.

Social proof is evidence that something is popular — that others have endorsed it. By creatively and soundly displaying social proof, ecommerce website managers can stack the deck in their favor and generate more sales.

There are several types of social proof you should consider implementing on your homepage:

  • Product reviews from purchasers — Product reviews are regarded as one of the most effective forms of social proof to use on ecommerce sites. Nearly 95% of shoppers read online reviews before making a purchase, and the purchase probability for a product with five reviews is 270% greater than the purchase probability of a product without them. If your website doesn’t include product reviews somewhere on the product page, you’re losing a substantial amount of business.
  • Customer testimonials — Requesting testimonials from prior customers can be a great way to build credibility and trust with your audience. These differ from product reviews in the way they are presented. Testimonials are concise recommendations that are placed in a call-out format. If product reviews are the backbone of social proof, testimonials are the face. Including video testimonials with your written testimonials is a particularly powerful tactic.
  • Earned media and press — If recognizable media brands have endorsed your company, you should definitely be leveraging this earned media on your homepage.

Step 3: Reevaluate Your Black Friday & Cyber Monday Sales Strategy

After conducting a thorough review of your website and optimizing your user experience to meet your customers’ needs, it’s time to review your selling strategy for the BFCM season. How are you going to drive the highest return on investment from your promotions?

What promotions will you offer?

If your current strategy is to rely on discounting to bring in new customers, it might be time to start thinking outside the box. Here are three ways you can optimize the impact of your planned BFCM campaigns to compete with big brands like Amazon, Walmart, Best Buy, and Apple.

1. Offer free shipping

Local retailers often counter the “I can get it cheaper online” objection with “Not after you add on the cost of shipping.” And while the reality is that free shipping plans often fail to provide significant cost savings to consumers (the expense must be covered somehow), conversion rates typically take a healthy leap forward when free shipping is featured. Just use Amazon Prime as an example.

Here are several recommendations for how to offer free shipping without destroying your margins:

  1. Free shipping threshold. A popular way to offer free shipping is having a certain cart threshold visitors need to reach before they unlock free shipping. Customers who are close to reaching the order amount for free shipping will very likely tack on additional products to reach the required threshold. That, in turn, can push your average order value up considerably and help make up for the absorbed shipping cost.
  2. Free shipping to members. This is a great way to improve customer retention while also growing your mailing list. You can charge for membership or not, but helping people feel like they’re a part of your business and giving them a good reason for shopping with you are good ideas.
  3. Free shipping to limited locations. Given the often exorbitant cost of shipping abroad, many ecommerce stores will offer free shipping only to those in their own country. Another possibility here is to offer free shipping from the distribution center to a local retail outlet. Be sure to spell out which locations qualify for free shipping.
  4. Flat rate shipping. This isn’t a free shipping offer, but it does alleviate much of the shopper’s anxiety. Those who know what the shipping cost will be before loading up the cart are more likely to follow through and place the order than those who don’t know how much shipping costs will be until they’re ready to pay. This tactic is especially effective when higher-priced items are ordered. A $5 flat rate shipping on a $150 order is far more attractive than $5 shipping on a $12 order.

2. Exploit the FOMO

Remember to create a sense of urgency around your campaigns. The fear of missing out (FOMO) can draw sales from people who might otherwise abandon a shopping cart and not return to complete the sale.

Here are a few ideas to help get you started:

  • Displaying “limited quantities available” on popular products
  • Offer exclusive offers or priority buying privileges to loyalty program members
  • Display sold-out items to encourage users to sign-up for a back-in-stock notification
  • Implement a free shipping countdown timer

3. Don’t lean on discounting

Shoppers love sales. Any reason you can come up with to hold one — be it Black Friday, Memorial Day, or your ecommerce birthday — is sure to boost revenue. There’s just one problem with the idea. “On Sale” means a discounted price, and a discounted price means less profit.

Yes, a properly orchestrated sales strategy can make up for the slimmer margin by pumping up the volume. The problem is, you end up sacrificing profits for the reputation of your brand.

Discounting leads customers to think that you’re a discount brand. Instead of being known for quality products or outstanding service, customers associate your company with the lowest price.

You become the ecommerce version of Dollar General, attracting those searching for bargains. When a customer receives a discount on their first purchase, you can be pretty confident that they’re going to try to get the same discount with every subsequent purchase.

Do you really want to join other discount brands in a race to the bottom? Instead, focus on Black Friday Deals that add value for your customers.

Segment & Grow Your Customer Base

Segmentation delivers results. Ecommerce managers who take the time to identify customer segments and tailor messages specific to each segment, consistently see ROI boosts that justify those efforts. People like to feel like you’re speaking directly to them, not just blasting out generic sales pitches to the masses. The more you know about your prospects, the better you’ll be at influencing their buying decisions.

There are two levels that should be considered in market segmentation: product fit and customer fit. Some would see this as the difference between business-to-business or business-to-consumer sales.

Remember, though, that buying decisions are made by people. Whether you’re selling to a corporation or a homemaker, you still need to be concerned about individual preferences.

At The Good, we tend to look at segmentation as either bottom up or top down.

Top-down segmentation begins with the product or service and seeks to fit the offer to the most lucrative segments of the available markets.

Bottom-up segmentation focuses on the buyer’s preferences and style, then works to get the best messaging to the right customers. An offshoot of bottom-up segmentation is the preparation of customer personas.

Neither approach is best. Insight from both is needed to develop the most effective marketing plan. The aim of market segmentation is to know what matters, where it matters, and when it matters. The end result of market segmentation is the division of your viable market into clusters of buyers with similar needs and desires.

Market segmentation research is the basis of determining your most effective marketing mix.

It’s Never Too Late to Start Optimizing

Be prepared to adjust your strategy to meet changing needs and demands. If a certain offer or campaign isn’t working for you, make the necessary adjustments to ensure that the rest of the season goes smoothly.

It’s OK to change up your ecommerce strategy as long as you’re making changes based on data, not assumptions.

If you’re still not sure what to start improving on your website or don’t have time to manage optimization on your own, you might consider bringing in a conversion optimization expert to lend a hand.

For over a decade, The Good has successfully increased conversions for brands large and small including Nike, Adobe, Xerox, The Economist, and many others.

If you’re interested in learning more about our approach to conversion optimization and how we can help improve your website experience, the best place to start is by booking a free landing page teardown.

This teardown is a data-driven critique of the usability and effectiveness of any landing page on your site. It’s developed using data from our insight platforms as well as an expert analysis by members of The Good’s Conversion and UX Strategy team.

Originally published on



The Good

Our mission is to remove all the bad digital experiences until only the good remain, so ecommerce companies can realize their full potential.